Hey, Gloucester: Where do babies come from?
Hey there. This is Meg, filling in for Steve. Want a warm-up on that coffee? You know, it’s weird. That Gloucester High School “pregnancy pact” left me with strange cravings for answers to questions that went largely unanswered in the mainsream media coverage…
In following the media circus that ensued after the 17th teenager became pregnant in a year in Gloucester, MA, I noticed no shortage of theories on what went wrong.
Many articles cite young Jamie Lynn Spears’ early motherhood and the new movie Juno as reasons pregnancy has become “cool.” While the media must share in all society’s ills, it seems to me that the portrayal of pregnant teens in popular culture is a mere reflection of their continued presence. Ignoring teen pregnancy is not the answer.
Some of those same articles also faulted maternity clothing designers for making pregnancy more comfortable for fashion-conscious teens. Until Hannah Montana comes out with her own line of “materniteen” wear, however, I’m not going to fault Liz Lange for making pregnancy chic.
Some blamed depressed economic conditions in the small fishing town. They postulate that the girls felt there was no way to move up from their station in life. Maybe they were so depressed about their future prospects that the teens wanted a baby to love them unconditionally?
Though there is no government data beyond the last census on the growing financial troubles many writers point to as a reason for the increase in childbirth in Gloucester, it can be helpful to look at data from 2000. At that time, the national poverty rate was 12.4 percent, Massachusetts was 9.3 percent, and Gloucester was 8.8 percent.
Even if newer numbers do end up supporting claims of economic depression in the town, I’d caution those who suggest that’s the reason for baby season in Gloucester. Let’s give these girls some credit: They all know a baby is not the solution to financial problems.
Cuts in education funding combined with the constant test preparation mandated by No Child Left Behind meant that the Gloucester High School had to cut their sex education classes. Also, the school’s clinic is prohibited from distributing contraception to students due to protests from the hospital that grants operational money to the facility. In May, the clinic was left sorely understaffed when the doctor and nurse practitioner resigned in protest over the contraceptives ban.
“This is one of the most outrageous things I have ever been a part of in my career,” said Dr. Brian Orr after turning in his resignation.
According to a recent AP report, there are only 28 states still enrolled in federal abstinence-only education programs. Almost half have opted out to avoid teaching restrictions and funding insecurity that have become par for the course in the program, known as Title V.
A House Congressional study analyzing the content of abstinence-only education should give educators considering Title V pause. The 2004 study found that two-thirds of abstinence-only curriculums included errors and distortions about public health, contraceptives, abortion, and basic scientific facts. The report also criticized certain programs’ use of religious language and use of stereotypes about the differences between the sexes.
In comparing two state-by-state studies (online here and here), I found a correlation between abstinence-only education and teen pregnancy rates. In 2006, the three states that received the most funding for abstinence-only programs were Texas, Florida and New York. Those states were fifth, sixth, and fourteenth in terms of teen pregnancies that same year. Vermont and North Dakota had the lowest amount of federal money devoted to abstinence-only programs and also had the least amount of teen pregnancies in 2006.
A more recent study shows students who receive comprehensive sexual education are 50 percent less likely to become pregnant than students subjected to abstinence-only education.
I don’t mean to suggest that sex education will end teen pregnancy as we know it. Young women already know that babies don’t come from storks. However, I’m young enough to remember sex education class, and it’s not the condom-over-the-banana lesson I remember most.
I recall vividly watching a video of a woman giving birth. It was frighteningly real and made it clear that childbirth is not for the weak or unprepared. Not that I was ever really inclined to reproduce, but that video convinced me that any of my potential progeny should come from an adoption center and not my womb.
However, statistics and personal anecdotes bear little on Congressional proceedings on the matter. As Steve wrote last week, Democrats are laying pretty low on the issue. So low, in fact, that they increased funding for abstinence-only education even while more and more states are opting out.
Still, there’s something extra fishy in Gloucester, and it’s not coming from the port. Teen pregnancies have been on the rise nationally over the past few years according to a 2007 Centers for Disease Control report.
The report shows that between 2005 and 2006, the birth rate for teenagers 15-19 years rose 3 percent to 41.9 births per 1,000. This follows a 14-year downward trend in which the teen birth rate fell by 34 percent from its last peak in 1991.
However, Gloucester High School’s average of annual teen pregnancies is still well above the currently heightened national average. According to school officials, an average of four students become pregnant in a typical year, putting their average at more than 60 per 1,000. The national average is about one third less. The 17 pregnancies for this year put the school way above average, at around 280 teen pregnancies per 1,000.
In the Time Magazine article that broke the story, Gloucester High School Principal Joseph Sullivan claimed some of the girls entered a pact to become pregnant together.
At a news conference days after the story broke, Gloucester Mayor Caroline Kirk said there was no evidence to back up Sullivan’s pregnancy pact theory.
“He was foggy in his memory of how he heard about the information,” Kirk said. “When we pressed him for specifics, about who told him, when was he told, his memory failed.” No media outlet has been able to reach Sullivan for comment since.
Kirk’s denial of Sullivan’s assertion raised more questions for me. Why would Sullivan make up a pregnancy pact to explain the rising trend? Which is worse: young girls bonding together to make poor decisions or a big spike in young couples independently making unfortunate choices?
But whether a pact was actually made is immaterial. There are multiple reports of students rejoicing at the receipt of a positive pregnancy test. Reporters trawling fast food restaurants and playgrounds found plenty of extremely young mothers who were very happy with their station in life. There is something about Gloucester that turns teen pregnancy from a crisis to a blessing, and the rest of us may never understand it.
Adolescence is a time when young adults get to start making their own decisions. If girls in Gloucester, or anywhere else, decide to pick out onesies for their babies instead of college majors for themselves, we cannot blame the media, the economy, or anyone other than the girls themselves.
However, in order to determine this was a decision made via free will and not the absence of alternatives, we need to make sure today’s young women know what’s out there. They need to have access to college preparation materials and birth control. They need to be told about the multifarious joys and difficulties of post-secondary education, employment, and childrearing.
Childbirth is a miracle and a blessing for many. So are education and birth control.
July 2nd, 2008 at 9:36 pm
Haven’t they heard about birth control pills? When the hormones flow condoms are not the 1st thing that comes to young peoples mind. And along with that video you watched, how about all the stories about over-population and starving people?
July 3rd, 2008 at 1:19 pm
Condoms should be the FIRST thing both sexes think about when having sex. No party without the balloons! It would be great if progressive and liberal media would incorporate the use of condoms into mainstream thought, like they used to and often still do with product placement. As a female, I have always felt responsible for my own body and that included pregnancy prevention. But let us not forget that it takes two to tango: why has no one asked about the sperm donors in this cozy little town of Gloucester. As per usual, these teen pregnancies are treated as if they were the result of parthenogenesis. Was there a great big hook-up party in town, where many of these girls were impregnated? There is probly some record of the event on YOU-TUBE, or GIRLS GONE WILD.
July 3rd, 2008 at 2:13 pm
Condoms are 99.9% effective as a birth control device. But when those hormones really get excited, and I’m referring especially to younger teens, consequences are not the 1st thing that comes to mind so they don’t get used as often as they should. When male birth control pills are perfected, I’ll advocate their use also. Birth control pills however, do not control for STDs, so I advocate the use of condoms. It’s just that when these youngsters have raging hormones, that is not the immediate concern.
July 6th, 2008 at 4:53 pm
Remind me sometime to tell a short tale about the time I was stationed in Korea on the North side of the Imjin River and a town just barely on the south side that we called “Last Chance Ville”. It seems about right given the name of the cafe and the subject of this entry.
July 6th, 2008 at 11:48 pm
What a week, I’ve partied at my class reunion (40th!), celebrated the birthday of a good friend and enjoyed the fireworks (got some great pics)………….I need a good old tall tale to get the fog out of my head!
Tell me the story of where Korean babies come from and/or Korean Kondoms in the ville.
July 7th, 2008 at 3:21 pm
Paula: This is not a tall tale. It is also not something I’m particularly proud of. It is just what happens when young men’s’ hormones are raging and you are in a military environment. It will take a little time for me to put it all together in some sort of coherent piece but I will send it when I’m ready. Right now I’ve had too much beer & need a nap.
(He always has too much beer. I don’t know why he’s not fat.)
July 7th, 2008 at 8:31 pm
Hope: here’s a story.
Walking over the Cascades one day with the dog and the dog’s pet cat (That’s me, Scout,) we came along a stream and then a lake. It was a nice warm day and we weren’t going anywhere we had to be at at any time. I could see a couple fish jumpin’ so I asked the dog if it would wouldn’t be nice just to stop for a while and let me fish a spell. He made some noises, then his pet cat did, and they both laid down in the shade of a tree. I think the cat swayed him a bit bit because she loves fish. In fact, I don’t doubt that old Scout somehow led us there. (I did.)
Anyhow I took that as a yes, so we did.
It wasn’t long before I pulled the first one out. It was kinda small so I just through it in the grass. It flipped and flopped for just a moment before the dog and cat both jumped on it. The cat won that round over the dog and batted that little thing around a while before it finally died and she started eating it. I caught a few more a bit bigger and cooked them up for me shared them with the dog. The fish innards went back into the water and were quickly eaten by other fish and a few birds that got there quick.
Afterwards we all had a good nap, had more fish for supper, ( I had coffee with mine, but they don’t like coffee,) then we spent a comfortable night under the stars.
July 8th, 2008 at 1:37 pm
My Dad put a fishin pole in my hand as soon as I could hold it. I could tell fish stories all night…but don’t worry I won’t. Just one that relates to yours. We were in Canada, at a very remote little lake. It was May and the ice was just off and it was cold, barely above freezing in the morning, then warming up into the 60s in the afternoon. The guys had been cleaning fish out on the pier and throwing the heads and “innards” into the lake. Dad and I came boating up to the pier that evening and as always, I went to the front and prepared to secure the boat. Just as I put one foot on the pier, Dad put it in reverse and I almost did the splits right before I plunged into the icy, fishhead-filled water. I’ve never seen Dad run that fast or laugh that hard. I had on about four layers of clothes and by the time I drug myself out, I weighed too much to chase after him. Come to think of it….I still owe him for that one!
July 8th, 2008 at 1:41 pm
Hey, by the way, did you get my moth picture?
(Just making sure Scout didn’t delete it before he showed it to you)
July 8th, 2008 at 3:48 pm
Alwayshope, I also graduated from high school 40 years ago. However I have not seen or heard anything about my high school class having a reunion this year.
I have gone to past reunions, including my 20, 25, and 30 year high school reunions, and my 20 and 25 year college reunions, all back in Illinois. (I have been living in San Diego, California for many years).
July 8th, 2008 at 7:24 pm
Nope, haven’t seen it.
July 8th, 2008 at 9:40 pm
I try not to miss them, we have them every five years also. You should check on that classmates.com site or just search for your high school to get info on a reunion. It’s worth it to take the time to remember being 18 and so full of it. I had a blast especially since two of my really good HS girlfriends came for the first time. We hadn’t seen each other in over 35 years!
I hope you’re out of the fire zone, Mike.